During this period of ongoing supply constraints, the trust that fleet managers had with OEMs, upfitters, and dealers has been strained.   -  Photo: Canva

During this period of ongoing supply constraints, the trust that fleet managers had with OEMs, upfitters, and dealers has been strained. 

Photo: Canva

The past three years have taken an emotional toll on fleet managers as a result of the deterioration of trust between buyers and sellers. Today, the law of supply and demand is not working in the favor of fleet managers since they have lost their negotiating leverage.

A fleet manager’s buying power has diminished as vehicle acquisition prices have increased and fleet incentives have decreased. In fact, a growing number of managers fear that fleets may not see a return to strong incentives for some time to come.

In addition, there continue to be long lead times; canceled or deferred orders; and random price increases despite signed sales orders.

This has been the new norm over the past three years, exacerbating inflation, making it impossible for fleets to plan strategically, and creating missed revenue opportunities for companies unable to expand their businesses due to asset constraints.

Plus, fleet managers complain of dealers price gouging for emergency out-of-stock orders. I’ve had fleet managers tell me they will no longer do business with dealerships who have taken advantage of them during these sourcing constraints.

The New Era of Fleet Allocation Ordering

During this period of ongoing supply constraints, the trust that fleet managers had with OEMs, upfitters, and dealers has been strained. Fleet managers say they have had too many experiences over the past three years coping with erroneous information, adjusting to multiple price increases, and feeling betrayed by inadequate transparency from suppliers.

Here’s how one fleet manager put it: “I didn’t even get an allocation for vans and that is a big part of my fleet. I placed orders in 2022 and waited 10 months only to get a note telling me that the orders were canceled and that I would have to reorder 2023s at a $5K increase.”

OEM allocations continue to be an issue. Even large fleets that have been ordering from the same manufacturer for many years have received allocations far below their needs.

Orders have been canceled without warning. This makes asset management extremely challenging, especially for fleets that have been loyal buyers to an OEM.

For most fleets, there continues to be a shortfall in replacement orders that are needed to maintain traditional replacement schedules.

In 2023, ordering was slightly better with the average fleet taking delivery of about 50%-60% of its orders, but there continues to be a replacement vehicle deficit since 40% to 50% of the vehicles needed to be replaced that were not replaced. This has driven up overall fleet costs in 2023 with higher acquisition costs, elevated interest rates, and a spike in unscheduled maintenance.

Longer service lives and higher mileage negatively impact depreciation when the vehicle is remarketed. One silver lining for some fleets is the opportunity to source vehicles from different OEMs.

However, this can cause dissatisfaction on the part of some drivers who are partial to one brand or another. Also, some OEMs are so tight with inventory that they are hesitant to take on new customers.

Managing a fleet is challenging enough. These disruptions are making fleet professionals react and recreate entire processes. This can be overwhelming as there is constant pressure from internal customers to reduce costs and provide vehicles.

As one fleet manager told me: Managing success in the chaos isn’t easy. The trick is keeping up with these disruptions without burning out. But this is easier said than done.

Some of long-time fleet managers say they are contemplating leaving their jobs due to the added pressure, especially if they are at or near retirement age.

But it is not all one-sided. Other fleets say they have strong supplier relationships and lines of communication with OEMs and upfitters that have helped tremendously in gathering information that helps them better forecast and know when they will have access to inventory and ultimate delivery.

Time Heals All Wounds

The only way to reestablish trust is for a collective understanding of the issues between each party (suppliers and fleets) and a collective search for solutions, sometimes on an individual vehicle level.

There should be no blaming and there should be a sole focus on helping each party achieve their targets. This will involve lots of work, but with the right partners, it is easier to get it done.

Both suppliers and customers need to go the extra mile or two, but it is worthwhile since it strengthens the business relationship.

How do we repair the damage that was done to business trust? There is no magic bullet, but I believe that time heals all wounds. We need to return to our normal ordering cycles and order-to-delivery expectations need to be fulfilled to the satisfaction of all parties for trust to reemerge.

In the final analysis, we can’t just focus on the issues and challenges that make our jobs difficult, we have to look at them as opportunities to improve.

Regaining trust takes time.

Let me know what you think.

[email protected]

Originally posted on Automotive Fleet

About the author
Mike Antich

Mike Antich

Former Editor and Associate Publisher

Mike Antich covered fleet management and remarketing for more than 20 years and was inducted into the Fleet Hall of Fame in 2010 and the Global Fleet of Hal in 2022. He also won the Industry Icon Award, presented jointly by the IARA and NAAA industry associations.

View Bio